Open Letter to MacLean's magazine
Open Letter to MacLean's magazine: June 17
Dear MacLean's,
I just read your recent eNews from your mail list. Our school library prides itself in open and objective access to information for all patrons. We read your Universities edition every year. Despite the occasional statistical flaws, we usually buy extra copies for our faculty, parents and Gr.12 students. My current concern is not your special edition but rather the pattern of journalism recently displayed since the fall 2007.
As a high school library in Canada, we always try hard to purchase Canadian content; however, recent editions of MacLean's has disgruntled so many patrons, we are considering canceling our subscription. Despite your efforts to engage education markets with projects, initiatives, and free access, the 'shock and fear' theme represented by your recent covers is deteriorating the educational value of your periodical. Experienced readers may be able to filter out the obvious marketing ploy but teens are not so critical.
As an experienced librarian, I have used MacLean's content as a support resource for many courses but lately MacLean's is so gratuitous in 'fear culture' in an apparent effort to sell issues, we will be soon using your periodical as an example of journalistic hyperbole and debatable integrity. Rather than the objective and well written publication, that provided canadian content of integrity, we are now having to teach students to 'filter' out the 'pulp fiction'.
We may as well be reading Newsweek or the New York Times! Please forward this feedback to your editorial team.
In the spirit of national pride and fair selections and acquisitions, our school library will subscribe for one more year- as a period of grace. We hope to see improvement in the reliable Canadian news digest we once cherished! Feel free to respond to our concerns.
sincerely,
Al Smith
Kelowna





